|
Introduction
Today is quite an auspicious day of the year to be sharing
reflections on the printing industry. It was, after all, on
this very date, September 30, way back in 1452, that our industry
was born: the first copy of Johann Gutenberg’s Bible,
the first book printed using movable type, was printed in
Germany. This fact reminds us of the importance of print as
a medium for communication, and by extension, of the importance
of all of you here in this room.
I think it also puts this conference into perspective: it’s
been 553 years since the industry began, and we’re still
holding meetings to learn about and figure out the changes
in this industry.
But of course that’s normal. Nothing in this world stays
still – we need to adapt. In fact, adapting
is the key idea not only of my speech today, but I’d
say for our entire industry these days.
Your presence here is an acknowledgement not only of your
interest in the industry you’ve chosen to work in –
and the one I’ve worked in for the past 15 years –
but also of the challenges in which this industry currently
finds itself.
At a lecture at Harvard University almost two centuries ago,
American philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson characterized periods
of revolution as the most interesting times to live in, when,
as he said, “the old and the new stand side by side…when
the historic glories of the old can be compensated by the
rich possibilities of the new.”
By Emerson’s logic, the profound transformations we
are a part of make this a very interesting time to be involved
in the printing industry. Well, that’s a philosopher
for you. Personally, as a businessman, I’d prefer to
have 10% annual growth and a 62-cent dollar! The point is
that the coming years will be turbulent times, and all printers
will have to face new and major challenges.
More recently, business guru Michael Porter of Harvard Business
School wrote back in 2000 that although industry structures
normally change slowly, during periods of transformation many
related elements of an industry’s structure change rapidly
and at the same time. That’s where we find
ourselves today, when the future is unfolding at unprecedented
speed.
Outline
- Many macroeconomic and market factors are having an effect
on print, and in this speech I will summarize them. I will
not, unfortunately, be able to solve them, but I will share
some thoughts.
- After that, I will discuss the growing impact technology,
especially digital technology, is having on us, and how
we can use it to our advantage.
- Finally, I’ll discuss the new business model features
I think we will need to develop in order to survive and
thrive in the printing industry of today and tomorrow.
I. Market Factors
Let me start off with two important statistics about consolidation
I found in a very interesting presentation that Charles Pesko,
the managing director of InfoTrends, gave just a few months
ago at the ON DEMAND Printing and Publishing Conference:
- Since 1990, there has been a 20% reduction in North American
printing plants.
- Since 2000, an average of 1000 plants have left this
market every year.
The question is, WHY? First, a few macroeconomic factors.
As you know, globalization has meant we’re
facing increased competition from all sides, especially Asia
in our case. The rise of China as a new economic power doesn’t
affect us in timely niches such as printing daily newspapers
or even magazines, but it’s certainly having a considerable
impact on the book printing market and some commercial work
around the globe.
Another more recent factor not necessarily reflected in the
statistics I just cited is of course the impact of the US-Canadian
exchange rate. Over the past few years, a more North-South
supplier-customer axis had been developing, replacing some
of the older print trade routes across and within Canada.
The rising US debt and energy costs are of course helping
the Canadian dollar gain strength, weakening the Canadian
manufacturing sector. Many politicians, especially those currently
in power, would have us believe a strong dollar is a sign
of a strong economy. And for many people it is. But it seems
to me that too many people are downplaying the future impact
of the dollar on Canadian industry, especially in regions
like Ontario and Quebec.
Globalization, the foreign exchange rate, rising energy costs
and of course the Internet’s impact are the macroeconomic
factors that are adding to the changes we are all facing.
Ever expanding customers continue to merge and acquire, and
are in turn looking to consolidate their supplier base. They
want trustworthy suppliers who can simplify their work and
follow them wherever they are located.
What will that mean for us? It means that fewer suppliers
will be competing for the spending coming from fewer, larger
customers. But how do we ensure we’re one of the members
of the printing species who stays in the race and wins?
I think many of us would consider our industry to comprise
three types of printers: small, large, and mid-sized. A Research
and Markets report last week shows that despite continuing
consolidation, the North American printing industry is still
highly fragmented. The largest 50 companies hold only about
30 percent of the market. Most North American printers that
are considered “large” have annual revenues under
one billion dollars, and the majority of companies operate
one plant, employ fewer than 20 people, and have annual revenue
under $5 million.
Increasingly in the future, the pie will be split between
small niche players and large consolidators like Donnelley,
whose sheer size allows them to follow their customers everywhere
around the globe.
Some printers, who cannot compete with large players on geographical
reach, economies of scale and reinvestments, and cannot beat
small players on price or local service relationships, will
therefore have their challenges. We can expect to see more
streamlining and grouping together of operations, something
we at Transcontinental, like you, have been facing over the
past five years.
But this is by no means inevitable or true in every case.
Remember, it’s not the size of the company in the fight,
it’s the size of the fight in the company.
One possible way forward is to focus on printing niches. That
is, whatever you do, be the best at it, and the volume will
follow. You either have to be first, best, or different. At
Transcontinental, our approach to growth has been to try to
be the best in our niches by using a different approach. Hence
our investments in newspaper printing outsourcing, direct
marketing, and short-run book printing, to name a few of our
niches.
II. Digital Technology
The role of technology in the transformation of our industry
is self evident, and in many ways begs the niche-strategy
question. We all have to pick and choose which technology
upgrades we’ll spend our precious profits on in order
to remain competitive in today’s printing market.
Charles Pesko provides another interesting statistic about
our industry: despite consolidation, the digital revolution,
and the pricing pressure I just mentioned, print industry
revenue is still growing. In fact, between 1997 and 2005,
businesses calling themselves “digital printers”
accounted for most of this industry’s growth.
This point highlights the widening gap being created by digital
technology in our industry. And as that gap between digital
adopters and hangers on gets even wider, industry consolidation
only accelerates.
One of the digital changes proper to the print industry is
a suite of online premedia tools, which many of you are developing.
In the age of blackberries and GPS, customers are beginning
to take it as a given that if they can track a UPS package
at every touch point around the world, they should be able
to track their print jobs online. Such a tool will also enable
us all to do more targeted printing.
Another key digital innovation is integrated workflow tools
to standardize and simplify all processes. This is what big
customers are doing. If we also do so, it becomes easier for
them to do business with us. Make life easier for your client
and they’re more likely to keep you on board, as they
have less time to deal with too many suppliers.
But there is another side to this whole digital revolution,
the side we read and hear about in the media, precisely where
the revolution is unfolding. The emerging digital media environment
– begun by the internet and now incorporating cell phones,
blackberries, IPODs, specialty digital radio and television
channels, and more – has already created, even entrenched,
new consumption habits. It is responsible for the emergence
of new values that affect both readers and our printing activities.
The widening technology gap in the printing industry is a
reflection of – and response to – the much-discussed
“digital divide.” Tech-savvy consumers, workers
and customers are pulling away from luddites, demanding –
and getting – information instantaneously. The old saying
that the news is out of date as soon as it is printed used
to be a funny, smart-alecky epigram. But just last week the
venerable New York Times Company announced that it’s
cutting 500 jobs, or 4% of its workforce. The same day, Knight
Ridder’s Philadelphia Newspapers Inc. announced 100
job cuts.
This is no laughing matter; this is transformation well under
way. In fact, The New York Times Internet segment
is growing rapidly. It’s our job as printers to understand
how we can be on the winning side of this transformation –
to learn how to make digital work for us.
For print customers, digital media are popular because they
facilitate ROI measurement and consumer targeting,
which were already growing trends in all media and advertising
before the digital revolution began in the later ’90s.
When Rémi Marcoux, Transcontinental’s founder
and now Executive Chairman, came up with the Publi-Sac in
1978, adding colour to retail flyers and distributing them
door-to-door bundled together rather than inserted in newspapers,
which were on strike at the time, it was a fantastic business
solution. Today, distribution of the flyers in our Publi-Sac
is targeted down to the city block across Quebec, according
to consumer demographics.
The system works well, but online advertising has it much
easier. An online newspaper or magazine reader’s automatically
recorded mouse clicks are the digital equivalent not just
of someone watching them pick up their paper subscription
copy off their front porch, but then accompanying them everywhere
they take that issue and recording their eye movements across
every page they open.
Add in the information gathered through online subscriptions
and you’re targeting a lot closer to the mark –
not the city block, but the individual consumer, wherever
he or she accesses a digital portal – computer or Blackberry.
Using this same thinking, advanced database management allows
printers to target two or two million individual consumers
with direct mail pieces across the continent, then record
the demographic information of respondents to the piece one
at a time.
The rich ROI data digital media affords is creating
two major market trends we can anticipate and prepare
for wisely.
Number 1: Increased targeting and specialization
naturally creates a multiplication of the number of products
being printed, with lower volume for each. More, shorter-run
print jobs is where the market is going (e.g. Catalogues:
retailers who went Internet are now back printing catalogues).
Number 2: Decreased waste. That means less
waste for the customer by printing closer to actual needs,
so that they can spend more on the quality of each printed
unit within the same budget. For example, typically about
50% of magazines delivered to retail vendors are not purchased,
and go to the recycling bin. With better information, we can
deliver quantities much closer to a store’s actual needs.
The publisher can then put more money into the look of his
product rather than wasted volume. This is of course better
for the environment, always an important consideration.
Knowing these trends, we can see how the digital revolution
can be seen not as a threat to our industry, but as complementary
to it, and thus an opportunity.
III. Business Model adjustments
As Charles Darwin put it first, and best: “It is not
the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent,
but those most responsive to change.”
That’s an important principle that underlies every natural
process on this planet, including industry evolution. In our
industry, that means it’s not just the big players who
will survive. Any printer who is to survive has to respond
to change in our marketplace, and many have already glimpsed
a way forward. Value-added services offer the promise of higher
margins and additional revenue growth. As value-added services
will make up an increasingly larger part of printers’
revenues, printers are transforming themselves into business
communications service providers. Of course, the transformation
is only worthwhile if we do not give away those services for
free. Many of us still have a tendency to think “I’m
getting a large volume on this job, so I’ll throw in
the services.” But we should not be shy to sell services,
even if we are not used to it. That’s how IBM makes
money today.
So we have to change our business models to sell what our
customers are now looking to buy. Is it simply print? Or is
it confidence in their documents, or improved marketing communications
to reach their consumers? We have to take the traditional
supplier role of anticipating our customers’ needs one
step further – we need to know where consumers, the
customers of our customers, are heading. Once we know that,
we take on the role of trusted consultant, of partner. We
become indispensable, able to accompany our customer at more
touch points in their supply chain as we evolve along with
them.
At Transcontinental, to better assume our role as a consultant
and partner, we’ve developed our market-team approach.
We divide our sales representatives by market sector –
for example road maps and atlases, or educational books –
so that they can become experts in that market, advising clients
of industry trends and consumer tendencies. That’s just
one example of a value-added service that we hope will strengthen
and cement our role as marketing advisor and business partner
to our customers, whether they are corporations, publishers,
or major financial institutions.
Taken along with the increased competition from around our
shrinking, globalizing planet, we can see why it’s so
important for Canadian printers to ensure our services are
stronger than ever, to remain attractive to customers both
at home and abroad.
Now, if we’re going to build our services rather than
our size, that growth is going to centre around talent. In
the end, all business operations can be reduced to three words,
people, product and profits. People come first. A printing
company isn’t presses and telephones; it’s pressmen,
sales agents, and everyone else who helps you advance the
ball.
So if you’re going to spend money on your company, spend
some on the people you pay to get the job done. Empower your
employees to think for themselves, report on their contact
with customers, help you eliminate inefficiencies and see
opportunities. Empower your leaders to encourage that input,
coach their direct reports for success, and improve your processes.
Empower your company to think like its customers and grow
organically alongside them.
But those points could apply to almost any company. Turning
to print, there are two issues I’ve
observed in my 15 years in this industry that are particular
to it, and have been my pet projects to overcome.
The first is that up until maybe five years
ago, it would be fair to say that the salesperson was the
point of contact for the client and determined the pricing
of print jobs. That meant that one person, the salesperson,
often made more money than the company on a particular job.
That’s crazy!
Today, more and more, the customer belongs to the company,
not the salesperson. Although they continue to be very important,
salespeople do not own the customer. If a company is to grow
– and grow profitably – it will need to have multiple
points of contact at different levels of the organization
with customers, to reinforce the service relationship.
The second observation I’d make about
this industry is the mentality I call “build it and
they will come.” That is, buy the presses and finishing
equipment, then fill it later with print jobs. That has been
a major driving force toward the overcapacity and pricing
pressure we’re experiencing today. When times get tough,
such as they are now, the thinking is “lower prices
to keep the presses running – at any cost.” We
all know – or if we didn’t already know, we’re
learning fast – that nobody wins in a price war.
So how should we try to apply the new business model, the
printer-as-partner approach, especially in the current climate
of extreme pricing pressure? At this point I’d like
to share three thoughts on how we try to apply this model
at Transcontinental.
Number 1: We don’t lower prices by
adding capacity. That’s skirting the problem and directly
making it worse. Instead, we replace presses with more efficient
machines – that is, we spend money to save money –
without adding capacity. In several recent cases, we’ve
replaced two or three older machines with one new, more efficient
one. But we’ll wait until we need more capacity before
adding it.
Number 2: We help our customers with their
workflow, so they can cut their costs internally
or, in some instances, outsource part of their work to us.
We now do a lot of premedia work for our customers.
And Number 3: We develop, then offer customers
more printing and value-added services, so they deal with
fewer suppliers and get a lower, aggregated price from us.
The more touch points in their supply chain we have, the more
indispensable we become.
Conclusion
At Transcontinental, we’ll be unveiling a new business
project in November, the continuation and extension of the
Horizon 2005 project we launched back in 2001. Because
I’ve spoken frankly and honestly today, the new plan
will reflect, as much as possible, what I’ve talked
about here, with the ultimate goal of adapting to our new
business environment in print as well as in our print media
operations.
But beginning Phase 2 of Horizon 2005 doesn’t
mean we think we have all the answers. In fact, it is an admission
that we don’t. I told you at the top of this speech
that over 550 years into this industry we’re still learning
and adapting. The important thing is not just to recognize
the issues, but to find solutions to those issues and then
execute, execute, execute. If much of what I’ve said
today seems like old news to you, you’re already ahead
of the game. Congratulations, and I’m sure we have something
to learn from you.
At Transcontinental we hope and believe we’re on the
right track, and we’re willing to take the risks involved
to execute our ideas, to turn our beliefs into action. I am
sure many of you also have great business plans and are doing
the same. And as you do so, never forget that every company,
no matter how big or small, is a work in progress. |